Digital Repression and Its Implications for Civic Space in Indonesia During the Covid-19 Pandemic: A Narrative Review

  • Siti Witianti
  • Caroline Paskarina
  • Lenny Meilany
  • Muhammad Andi Firmansyah

Abstract

The state of crisis and emergency due to Covid-19 has been exploited by governments of many countries, both autocratic and democratic, to intensify surveillance and restrict freedom of online expression. Indonesia is no exception. This article studies how digital repression occurred in Indonesia during the Covid-19 pandemic and its implications for civil society's space for movement and maneuver. We use a narrative review method by adopting PRISMA (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses) criteria. We found that the Indonesian government practices all forms of digital repression conceptualized by Feldstein (2020): surveillance, censorship, social manipulation and disinformation, internet shutdowns, and targeted persecution of online users. All these forms of digital repression have indeed contributed to the weakening and shrinking of the civic movement in Indonesia to some degree. However, new resistance and maneuvers continue to emerge. Dissent always seems to find a way to seep out of the undercurrent in the face of repression, both offline and online. This article makes an important contribution to understanding the landscape and dynamics of digital repression in Indonesia, particularly during the Covid-19 pandemic, and helps in projecting the opportunities and challenges for civic movements in the post-pandemic period.

References

Afifa, L. (2021, August 31). Moeldoko Files Police Report Against ICW over Ivermectin. Tempo. https://en.tempo.co/read/1500901/moeldoko-files-police-report-against-icw-over-ivermectin
Agamben, G. (2008). State of exception (K. Attell, Trans.; Nachdr.). University of Chicago Press.
Agamben, G. (2020, February 26). L’invenzione di un’epidemia. Quodlibet. https://www.quodlibet.it/giorgio-agamben-l-invenzione-di-un-epidemia
Alami, A. N., Luong, D. N. A., Prihatini, E., Ramadhani, E., Go, J. R. R., Hafidzah, N., & Atiyah, U. (2023). Democratization in the Digital Era: Experience from Southeast Asia. JAS (Journal of ASEAN Studies), 10(2), 227–246. https://doi.org/10.21512/jas.v10i2.9361
AlAshry, M.-S. (2024). Arab journalists have no place: Authorities use digital surveillance to control investigative reporting. Communication & Society, 37(1), 61–77. https://doi.org/10.15581/003.37.1.61-77
Alvina, H., Julianti, L., Sugiantari, A. A. P. W., & Udytama, I. W. W. W. (2022). The State of Digital Freedom in Indonesia an Assessment of Online Censorship, Privacy, and Free Expression. Journal of Digital Law and Policy, 1(3), 141–152. https://doi.org/10.58982/jdlp.v1i3.301
Amnesty International. (2021a). Report 2020/21: The state of the world’s human rights (POL 10/3202/2021). Amnesty International. https://www.amnesty.org/en/wp-content/uploads/2021/06/POL1032022021ENGLISH.pdf
Amnesty International. (2021b). Silenced and Misinformed: Freedom of Expression in Danger During Covid-19 (POL 30/4751/2021). Amnesty International. https://www.amnesty.org/en/documents/pol30/4751/2021/en/
Armiwulan, H. (2022). The Limitation of Freedom of Expression by State as a Crime during Pandemic Covid-19 in Indonesia. International Journal of Criminal Justice Sciences (IJCJS), 17(2), Article 2.
Asyari, H. A. (2023). Between Freedom And Protection: A Critical Review Of Indonesia’s Cyberspace Law. Prophetic Law Review, 5(1), 79–103. https://doi.org/10.20885/PLR.vol5.iss1.art5
Barceló, J., Kubinec, R., Cheng, C., Rahn, T. H., & Messerschmidt, L. (2022). Windows of repression: Using COVID-19 policies against political dissidents? Journal of Peace Research, 59(1), 73–89. https://doi.org/10.1177/00223433211062389
Cassani, A. (2022). COVID-19 and the Democracy–Autocracy Freedom Divide: Reflections on Post-Pandemic Regime Change Scenarios. Political Studies Review, 20(4), 717–724. https://doi.org/10.1177/14789299211047087
Corpuz, J. C. G. (2021). COVID-19 and the rise of social activism in Southeast Asia: A public health concern. Journal of Public Health, 43(2), 364–365. https://doi.org/10.1093/pubmed/fdab063
Croissant, A., & Diamond, L. (2020). Reflections on Democratic Backsliding in Asia: An Introduction. Global Asia, 15(1), 8–14.
Davenport, C. (1995). Multi-Dimensional Threat Perception and State Repression: An Inquiry into Why States Apply Negative Sanctions. American Journal of Political Science, 39(3), 683–713. https://doi.org/10.2307/2111650
Deibert, R., & Rohozinski, R. (2011). Contesting Cyberspace and the Coming Crisis of Authority. In Access Contested: Security, Identity, and Resistance in Asian Cyberspace (pp. 21–41). The MIT Press. https://doi.org/10.7551/mitpress/9780262016780.003.0002
Desyana, S. R. (2022, April 8). PeduliLindungi: To Care for and Protect? EngageMedia. https://engagemedia.org/2022/pandemic-control-pedulilindungi/
Dragu, T., & Lupu, Y. (2021). Digital Authoritarianism and the Future of Human Rights. International Organization, 75(4), 991–1017. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0020818320000624
Earl, J., Maher, T. V., & Pan, J. (2022). The digital repression of social movements, protest, and activism: A synthetic review. Science Advances, 8(10), eabl8198. https://doi.org/10.1126/sciadv.abl8198
Eck, K., & Hatz, S. (2020). State surveillance and the COVID-19 crisis. Journal of Human Rights, 19(5), 603–612. https://doi.org/10.1080/14754835.2020.1816163
Farisa, F. C., & Krisiandi. (2020, June 23). Mahfud: Presiden Minta Aparat Tak Terlalu Sensitif, Apa-apa Ditangkap. Kompas.com. https://nasional.kompas.com/read/2020/06/23/19355701/mahfud-presiden-minta-aparat-tak-terlalu-sensitif-apa-apa-ditangkap
Feldstein, S. (2021a). Social Manipulation and Disinformation in the Philippines. In S. Feldstein, The Rise of Digital Repression (1st ed., pp. 134–176). Oxford University PressNew York. https://doi.org/10.1093/oso/9780190057497.003.0005
Feldstein, S. (2021b). The rise of digital repression: How technology is reshaping power, politics, and resistance. Oxford University Press.
Forum Asia. (2021). Repressive laws summary, Jan-Mar 2021. Forum Asia. https://hrlaw.forum-asia.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/07/Q1-Repressive-laws-summary-1.pdf
Germanò, M. A., Liu, A., Skebba, J., & Jili, B. (2023). Digital Surveillance Trends and Chinese Influence in Light of the COVID-19 Pandemic. Asian Journal of Comparative Law, 18(1), 91–115. https://doi.org/10.1017/asjcl.2022.31
Gibson, J. L., & Sutherland, J. L. (2023). Keeping Your Mouth Shut: Spiraling Self-Censorship in the United States. Political Science Quarterly, 138(3), 361–376. https://doi.org/10.1093/psquar/qqad037
Glowacka, D., Youngs, R., Pintea, A., & Wolosik, E. (2021). Digital technologies as a means of repression and social control. European Parliament. https://data.europa.eu/doi/10.2861/6706
Gohdes, A. R. (2020). Repression Technology: Internet Accessibility and State Violence. American Journal of Political Science, 64(3), 488–503. https://doi.org/10.1111/ajps.12509
Gohdes, A. R. (2024). Repression in the digital age: Surveillance, censorship, and the dynamics of state violence. Oxford University Press.
Gregorio, G. D., & Stremlau, N. (2020). Internet Shutdowns and the Limits of Law. International Journal of Communication, 14, Article 0.
Halliday, S., Meers, J., & Tomlinson, J. (2020, May 8). Public Attitudes on Compliance with COVID-19 Lockdown Restrictions. UK Constitutional Law Association. https://ukconstitutionallaw.org/2020/05/08/simon-halliday-jed-meers-and-joe-tomlinson-public-attitudes-on-compliance-with-covid-19-lockdown-restrictions/
International Federation of Journalists. (2020, August 25). Indonesia: Media organisations targeted by digital attacks. International Federation of Journalists. https://www.ifj.org/media-centre/news/detail/category/press-releases/article/indonesia-media-organisations-targeted-by-digital-attacks
Jamil, S. (2021). The rise of digital authoritarianism: Evolving threats to media and Internet freedoms in Pakistan. World of Media. Journal of Russian Media and Journalism Studies, 3(3), 5–33. https://doi.org/10.30547/worldofmedia.3.2021.1
Jones, M. O. (2019). Propaganda, Fake News, and Fake Trends: The Weaponization of Twitter Bots in the Gulf Crisis. International Journal of Communication, 13, Article 0.
Jung, E. (2022). Indonesia: From the Pandemic Crisis to Democratic Decline. In Populists and the Pandemic. Routledge.
Juniarto, D. (2022, July 5). A COVID-19 power grab: Looming digital authoritarianism in Indonesia. EngageMedia. https://engagemedia.org/2022/pandemic-control-indonesia/
Juniarto, D., Sanjaya, A. R., Banimal, A. H., Kusuma, E., Arum, N. S., Andaru, N. F., Syaifullah, & Sagena, U. (2022). Digital Rights in Indonesia Situation Report 2021: The Pandemic Might Be Under Control, but Digital Repression Continues. Southeast Asia Freedom of Expression Network (SAFEnet).
Khatami, M. I., & Pahlevi, Moch. E. T. (2022). Covid-19 dan Kebebasan Berekspresi di Internet: Melihat Represi Digital dalam Pemberitaan Tempo.co. SOURCE: Jurnal Ilmu Komunikasi, 8(1), 1–13. https://doi.org/10.35308/source.v8i1.4592
Kövér, Á. (2021). The Relationship between Government and Civil Society in the Era of COVID-19. Nonprofit Policy Forum, 12(1), 1–24. https://doi.org/10.1515/npf-2021-0007
Lin, P., Knockel, J., Poetranto, I., Tran, S., Lau, J., & Senft, A. (2020). Unmasked II: An Analysis of Indonesia and the Philippines’ Government-launched COVID-19 Apps (Citizen Lab Research Report No. 136). University of Toronto. https://citizenlab.ca/2020/12/unmasked-ii-an-analysis-of-indonesia-and-the-philippines-government-launched-covid-19-apps/
Lindsey, T., & Mann, T. (2020, August 12). Indonesia’s coronavirus fatalities are the highest in Southeast Asia. So, why is Jokowi rushing to get back to business? The Conversation. http://theconversation.com/indonesias-coronavirus-fatalities-are-the-highest-in-southeast-asia-so-why-is-jokowi-rushing-to-get-back-to-business-144059
Lorch, J., & Sombatpoonsiri, J. (2023). COVID-19 and Civil Society in Southeast Asia: Beyond Shrinking Civic Space. VOLUNTAS: International Journal of Voluntary and Nonprofit Organizations, 34(3), 613–625. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11266-022-00496-1
Maharani, T., & Erdianto, K. (2021, March 17). Polri Berencana Berikan Lencana Penghargaan bagi Warga yang Aktif Laporkan Dugaan Pidana di Medsos. Kompas.com. https://nasional.kompas.com/read/2021/03/17/18225311/polri-berencana-berikan-lencana-penghargaan-bagi-warga-yang-aktif-laporkan
Masduki. (2021). Media Control in the Digital Politics of Indonesia. Media and Communication, 9(4), 52–61. https://doi.org/10.17645/mac.v9i4.4225
Mietzner, M. (2021). Sources of resistance to democratic decline: Indonesian civil society and its trials. Democratization, 28(1), 161–178. https://doi.org/10.1080/13510347.2020.1796649
Mirzoyan, A. (2023). Digital Authoritarianism as a Modern Threat to Democratic Stability: Restriction of Freedom or Network Politicization? Journal of Political Science: Bulletin of Yerevan University, 2(3(6)), 62–75. https://doi.org/10.46991/JOPS/2023.2.6.062
Noroyono, B. (2021, January 3). Survei Komnas HAM Ungkap Ketakutan Warga Kritik Pemerintah. Republika Online. https://republika.co.id/share/qmcp8j409
Ong, E. (2021). Online Repression and Self-Censorship: Evidence from Southeast Asia. Government and Opposition, 56(1), 141–162. https://doi.org/10.1017/gov.2019.18
Pambudi, H. J., Nugroho, A. L. A., Handoko, L., & Dianastiti, F. E. (2021). Buzzer di Masa Pandemi Covid-19: Studi Analisis Wacana Kritis Kicauan Buzzer di Twitter. Jurnal Masyarakat Dan Budaya, 23(1), 75–89. https://doi.org/10.14203/jmb.v23i1.1265
Papineau, E. I. (2023). Locating DIY in the digital shift: Exploring grassroots activist responses to COVID-19 in Indonesia and the Philippines. DIY, Alternative Cultures & Society, 1(3), 242–255. https://doi.org/10.1177/27538702231203374
Paterson, T. (2019). Indonesian cyberspace expansion: A double-edged sword. Journal of Cyber Policy, 4(2), 216–234. https://doi.org/10.1080/23738871.2019.1627476
Putra, A., & Irwansyah. (2020). Orkestrasi Buzzer melalui Media Sosial Microblogging dalam Kampanye Penanganan Virus Covid-19. Jurnal Riset Komunikasi (Jurkom), 3(2), 267–288.
Putri, Z. A., & Herdiman, L. (2023). Regulations of Personal Data Privacy in PeduliLindungi Application. In S. U. Firdaus, Waluyo, E. Yuliandari, A. Suwandono, & D. B. Kharisma (Eds.), Proceedings of the Youth International Conference for Global Health 2022 (YICGH 2022) (Vol. 65, pp. 20–27). Atlantis Press International BV. https://doi.org/10.2991/978-94-6463-206-4_4
Ramadhan, R. (2022, August 5). Menkominfo Pamer Cyber Drone 9, Tim dan Mesin Blokir Internet Indonesia. Kumparan. https://kumparan.com/kumparantech/menkominfo-pamer-cyber-drone-9-tim-dan-mesin-blokir-internet-indonesia-1yaldon4Cme
Robet, R., Fitri, M. R., & Kabelen, M. C. S. (2023). The State and Human Rights under Joko Widodo’s Indonesia. Cogent Social Sciences, 9(2), 2286041. https://doi.org/10.1080/23311886.2023.2286041
Rohman, A. (2021). A Fused Resistance against State-Sponsored Hacking in Indonesia during COVID-19 Pandemic (SSRN Scholarly Paper 4331462). https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.4331462
Ryandi, D. (2020, August 21). Biaya Buzzer Rp 90-an Miliar, Riset Covid-19 Cuman Rp 5 Miliar. Jawa Pos. https://www.jawapos.com/politik/01284695/biaya-buzzer-rp-90an-miliar-riset-covid19-cuman-rp-5-miliar
Rydzak, J., Karanja, M., & Opiyo, N. (2020). Dissent Does Not Die in Darkness: Network Shutdowns and Collective Action in African Countries. International Journal of Communication, 14, Article 0.
Sanjaya, A. R., Banimal, A. H., Fundrika, B., Ningtyas, I., Saputri, N., Arum, N. S., Andaru, N. F., Supriyono, & Sagena, U. (2021). Laporan Situasi Hak-hak Digital Indonesia 2020: Represi Digital di Tengah Pandemi. Southeast Asia Freedom of Expression Network (SAFEnet).
Sastramidjaja, Y., & Rasidi, P. P. (2021). The Hashtag Battle over Indonesia’s Omnibus Law: From Digital Resistance to Cyber-Control. ISEAS Perspective, 95, 1–15.
Schlumberger, O., Edel, M., Maati, A., & Saglam, K. (2023). How Authoritarianism Transforms: A Framework for the Study of Digital Dictatorship. Government and Opposition, 1–23. https://doi.org/10.1017/gov.2023.20
Setiawan, K. M. P., & Tomsa, D. (2023). Defending a Vulnerable yet Resilient Democracy: Civil Society Activism in Jokowi’s Indonesia. Journal of Current Southeast Asian Affairs, 42(3), 350–371. https://doi.org/10.1177/18681034231209058
Setijadi, C. (2021). The Pandemic as Political Opportunity: Jokowi’s Indonesia in the Time of Covid-19. Bulletin of Indonesian Economic Studies, 57(3), 297–320. https://doi.org/10.1080/00074918.2021.2004342
Seyhan, E. (2020). Pandemic Powers: Why Human Rights Organizations Should Not Lose Focus on Civil and Political Rights. Journal of Human Rights Practice, 12(2), 268–275. https://doi.org/10.1093/jhuman/huaa035
Shahbaz, A., & Funk, A. (2020). The Pandemic’s Digital Shadow (Freedom on the Net 2020). Freedom House. https://freedomhouse.org/report/freedom-net/2020/pandemics-digital-shadow
Siagian, M., Yuliarti, M. S., & Universitas Sebelas Maret, Indonesia. (2021). Papua’s Internet Ban 2020: Politics, Information Democracy, and Digital Literacy. Jurnal Komunikasi: Malaysian Journal of Communication, 37(3), 304–316. https://doi.org/10.17576/JKMJC-2021-3703-18
Slater, D., & Arugay, A. A. (2018). Polarizing Figures: Executive Power and Institutional Conflict in Asian Democracies. American Behavioral Scientist, 62(1), 92–106. https://doi.org/10.1177/0002764218759577
Sombatpoonsiri, J., & Mahapatra, S. (2021). COVID-19 Intensifies Digital Repression in South and Southeast Asia (Issues on the Frontlines of Technology and Politics, pp. 1–5). GIGA Institute for Asian Studies. https://www.giga-hamburg.de/en/publications/contributions/covid-19-intensifies-digital-repression-in-south-and-southeast-asia
Steinert-Threlkeld, Z. C. (2017). Spontaneous Collective Action: Peripheral Mobilization During the Arab Spring. American Political Science Review, 111(2), 379–403. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0003055416000769
Suroyo, G., & Da Costa, A. B. (2020, April 23). Indonesian activist held over messages spreading “hatred”, rights groups say he was framed. Reuters. https://www.reuters.com/article/world/indonesian-activist-held-over-messages-spreading-hatred-rights-groups-say-he-idUSKCN225351/
Suryahadi, A., Al Izzati, R., & Suryadarma, D. (2020). Estimating the Impact of Covid-19 on Poverty in Indonesia. Bulletin of Indonesian Economic Studies, 56(2), 175–192. https://doi.org/10.1080/00074918.2020.1779390
Tempo. (2020, October 21). Tahun Represi Digital. Tempo. https://koran.tempo.co/read/cover-story/459058/tahun-represi-digital
The Institute for Criminal Justice Reform. (2020, April 23). [PERNYATAAN BERSAMA KOALISI TOLAK KRIMINALISASI DAN REKAYASA KASUS] Segera Lepaskan Ravio Patra, Hentikan Kriminalisasi, Ungkap Pelaku Peretasan! The Institute for Criminal Justice Reform. https://icjr.or.id/pernyataan-bersama-koalisi-tolak-kriminalisasi-dan-rekayasa-kasus-segera-lepaskan-ravio-patra-hentikan-kriminalisasi-ungkap-pelaku-peretasan/
Theocharis, Y., Lowe, W., Van Deth, J. W., & García-Albacete, G. (2015). Using Twitter to mobilize protest action: Online mobilization patterns and action repertoires in the Occupy Wall Street, Indignados, and Aganaktismenoi movements. Information, Communication & Society, 18(2), 202–220. https://doi.org/10.1080/1369118X.2014.948035
Ufen, A. (2024). The Rise of Digital Repression in Indonesia under Joko Widodo. GIGA Focus Asia, 1, 1–9. https://doi.org/10.57671/GFAS-24012
Uniacke, R. (2021). Authoritarianism in the information age: State branding, depoliticizing and ‘de-civilizing’ of online civil society in Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates. British Journal of Middle Eastern Studies, 48(5), 979–999. https://doi.org/10.1080/13530194.2020.1737916
Walker, S. (2021, July 18). Viktor Orbán using NSO spyware in assault on media, data suggests. The Guardian. https://www.theguardian.com/news/2021/jul/18/viktor-orban-using-nso-spyware-in-assault-on-media-data-suggests
Weidmann, N. B., & Rød, E. G. (2019). The Internet and Political Protest in Autocracies (1st ed.). Oxford University Press. https://doi.org/10.1093/oso/9780190918309.001.0001
Wibowo, E. A. (2021, May 6). Survei LP3ES: Publik Semakin Takut Menyatakan Pendapat. Tempo. https://nasional.tempo.co/read/1459846/survei-lp3es-publik-semakin-takut-menyatakan-pendapat
Wilson, R. A. (2022). Digital Authoritarianism and The Global Assault on Human Rights. Human Rights Quarterly, 44(4), 704–739. https://doi.org/10.1353/hrq.2022.0043
YLBHI. (2024, July 10). Kepolisian RI: Menegakkan Hukum dengan Melanggar Hukum dan HAM, Serta Mengancam Demokrasi. YLBHI. https://ylbhi.or.id/informasi/siaran-pers/kepolisian-ri-menegakkan-hukum-dengan-melanggar-hukum-dan-ham-serta-mengancam-demokrasi/
Published
2024-07-30
How to Cite
WITIANTI, Siti et al. Digital Repression and Its Implications for Civic Space in Indonesia During the Covid-19 Pandemic: A Narrative Review. E-JOURNAL OF MEDIA AND SOCIETY (E-JOMS), [S.l.], v. 7, n. 3, p. 62-79, july 2024. ISSN 2682-9193. Available at: <https://myjms.mohe.gov.my/index.php/ejoms/article/view/27215>. Date accessed: 09 nov. 2024.